Butter Street Sweets

Formerly Quintessential Cookies


Various items available in store.


Jumbo Cookies


We take cookie orders and ship anywhere in the continental U.S.

You can order through our online shop (coming soon) but to get truly custom, special cookies please call (631)262-0633 to place an order or stop by the store!


Specialty items.

Not all treats will be available all the time, stop by to see if a treat is in stock!